With the headlines fixated on our country’s possible debt default, I want to focus on the markets regarding this matter. Obviously, the prospects of a government shutdown and debt default can be frightening with unnerving propositions. So, what would such a default really lead to, and what are the markets telling us?
In a worst case scenario, we “could” see ratings agencies such as Moody’s, S&P and Fitch downgrade U.S. debt. Such downgrades would possibly be more damaging than the default itself as it would likely force increased selling pressure on all forms of U.S. debt, leading to higher interest rates and lower bond prices. Additionally, because we’re in a slow economic recovery rising interest rates would slow our recovery further, as borrowing costs would go up for companies and individuals.
History does not give us many comparisons for our current dilemma. But, it is worth remembering that we experienced government shutdowns in late 1995 and early 1996. In those instances, the stock market performed quite will. In fact, the Dow Jones was trading around 3800 in November 1994 and around 4900 at the time of shutdowns.
What we need to focus on is that the markets are a “discounting mechanism”. In other words, much of the fear of a shutdown was already “baked into the cake” in 1995 as the markets had anticipated a shutdown and adjusted/discounted accordingly. Of course, the prior results do not guarantee a positive outcome, but it does serve as a helpful antidote. What the markets cannot discount are occurrences and events which are truly unexpected and unanticipated. The markets know this issue is looming and arguably, investors have already discounted accordingly. Case in point, the S&P 500 is currently off about 5% from its highs and the markets have essentially gone sideways since January. This is against a backdrop of improving corporate earnings, with much of this scenario is already built into the markets.
At the end of the day, the capital markets are signaling that America will not default on its obligations. While our current situation itself is disconcerting, it should not have a very long lasting effect because corporate earnings, not politics, drive the capital markets.
